Skip to Content

Eggnog Gooey Butter Cookies (from scratch)

Eggnog gooey butter cookies are just like they sound; gooey, buttery, chewy cookies, with a subtle eggnog flavor, finished with a sprinkling of fresh grated nutmeg! The best Christmas cookie, makes a lot and all the flavors of the holidays!

Ever had a gooey butter cookie or cake? The texture is something between a dense and chewy brownie and a sugar cookie.

We love baking in our house, you might try some of our holiday favorites! Pan Banging Sugar Cookies (what!), Andes Mint Brownie Bites, Salted Chocolate Graham Bites and Greek Butter Cookies.

IMAGE of stack of eggnog gooey butter cookies with bite taken out of it. with nutmeg and spice grater in background.

What’s the Origin of Gooey Butter Cake?

The Gooey Butter Cake (preceding the gooey butter cookie) originated sometime around 1930’s – 1940’s. According to legend, a German baker added the wrong proportions of ingredients in the coffee cake batter he was making. It turned into a gooey, pudding-like filling.

But his flop became an overnight sensation! This story is contested by a few folks, it’s fun to read about.

Also made famous in more recent decades is the famous Paula Deen version of Gooey Butter Cake and cookies. I have a recipe that I have made for years for Pumpkin Gooey Butter Cake, but alas I haven’t put it on the blog yet! Soon!

image of 9 eggnog gooey butter cookies on cooling rack with powdered sugar in seive.

How to you make Eggnog Gooey Butter Cookies from Scratch?

Most gooey butter cookie recipes are made using cake mix. While I am not opposed to using a cake mix in a cookie (like these Cake Batter Chocolate Chip Cookies), these were too simple to whip up from scratch.

Eggnog vs. Egg Nog?

Apparently there are several variations of the spelling, the most common being eggnog, but also egg nog and egg-nog. I love it when I can’t mess up a spelling!

Are you an eggnog lover or hater? I LOVE IT! Well as much as you can “love” a deliciously, rich, holiday drink! The good news about this recipe is the eggnog doesn’t overpower the butter cookies, instead it enhances their flavor with traditional holiday essence.

I love baking with eggnog, like these Eggnog Scones; the mixture of milk, sugar and eggs make it ideal to add to baked goods.

INGREDIENTS

ingredients shot for eggnog butter cookies. L to R vanilla, flour, sugar, spices, and eggnog
Process shot for eggnog cookies. 1. butter, cream cheese, Greek yogurt in mixing bowl. 2. adding sugar. 3. mixing dry ingredients. 4. adding egg

Making Eggnog Butter Cookies

  1. In a large mixing bowl, stir or whisk together the flour, baking powder, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg and set aside.
  2. Beat cream cheese, butter and sour cream (or Greek yogurt) with a mixer until creamy.
  3. With mixer on low, slowly pour in sugar and cream mixture until smooth, scraping down the sides occasionally, about 2-3 minutes. Add the egg, eggnog and vanilla mixing on low until combined.
Eggnog cookies process shots 5. adding flour and eggnog 6. sticky batter 7. hand holding gooey cookie ball. 8. rolling ball in powdered sugar
  1. With the mixer on low/stir, gradually add the dry ingredients and mix until just combined. The dough will be very sticky, or gooey! Chill at least 30 minutes, longer if possible.
  2. Preheat the oven to 350F degrees; line a baking sheet with parchment paper or spray with non-stick spray. Using a small or medium cookie scoop, Form the dough into roughly 1-inch balls and roll in powdered sugar.
  3. I suggest you roll them all and place them all on one (lined) cookie sheet and return to fridge, pulling off only those you are baking. When baking place 2 inches apart on prepared cookie sheet.

  1. Bake for 10-12 minutes until edges have set and tops are just barely set, you don’t want to over bake these cookies, they will firm up as they cool.
  2. Allow cookies to cool on the baking sheet for 10-15 minutes before transferring to a cooling rack to cool completely.
  3. If desired make up a batch of browned butter glaze and drizzle on top of cooled cookies. And don’t forget the fresh nutmeg! Store in airtight container on counter for up to 1 week or freeze up to 6 months.
fresh grated nutmeg on top of eggnog gooey butter cookies

Make these as gifts and print out the gift tags below!

Print Out These Cute Free Christmas Gift Tags to go with your gift!

High Altitude Adjustments for Gooey Christmas Cookies

The only adjustment I made is to increase the flour slightly for high altitude baking, otherwise no changes. Measurements for sea level and high altitude are included in the recipe card below..

What are your favorite Christmas cookies? Pop below the recipe and leave me a comment! Happy baking!

PIN to your favorite Christmas Cookies board!

Pinterest image of stacked eggnog gooey butter cookies with nutmeg and grater in back

Like this recipe?
Don’t forget to give it a ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️star rating in the recipe below!

four eggnog butter cookies stacked one with bite of it.
Yield: 30-40 cookies

Eggnog Gooey Butter Cookies

Prep Time: 15 minutes
Cook Time: 10 minutes
Chill Time: 30 minutes
Total Time: 55 minutes

Eggnog gooey butter cookies are just like they sound, gooey, buttery, chewy cookies, with a subtle eggnog flavor, finished with a sprinkling of fresh grated nutmeg!

Ingredients

  • 2 3/4 cups All-purpose flour (sea level up to 3000 feet, use 2 1/2 cups)
  • 2 teaspoons Baking powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon Sea Salt
  • 3/4 teaspoon Cinnamon
  • 1/2 teaspoon Nutmeg
  • 1/2 cup Butter (salted or unsalted)
  • 4 oz Cream cheese (not fat free)
  • 1/2 cup Sour Cream or Greek Yogurt (I used Green yogurt, full fat)
  • 1 1/4 cups All natural cane sugar
  • 1 Large Egg
  • 1/3 cup Eggnog (full fat version)
  • 1 teaspoon Vanilla extract
  • Powdered Sugar for rolling
  • Ingredients for Brown Butter Glaze (if desired)
  • Fresh grated Nutmeg

Instructions

In a large mixing bowl, stir or whisk together the flour, baking powder, salt, cinnamon, nutmeg and set aside.

Beat cream cheese, butter and sour cream (or Greek yogurt) with a mixer until creamy.

With mixer on low, slowly pour in sugar and cream mixture until smooth, scraping down the sides occasionally, about 2-3 minutes. Add the egg, eggnog and vanilla mixing on low until combined.

With the mixer on low/stir, gradually add the dry ingredients and mix until just combined. The dough will be very sticky, or gooey! Chill at least 30 minutes, longer if possible.

Preheat the oven to 350F degrees; line a baking sheet with parchment paper or spray with non-stick spray. Using a small or medium cookie scoop, Form the dough into roughly 1-inch balls and roll in powdered sugar.

I suggest you roll them all and place them all on one (lined) cookie sheet and return to fridge, pulling off only those you are baking. When baking place 2 inches apart on prepared cookie sheet.

Bake for 10-12 minutes until edges have set and tops are just barely set, you don't want to over bake these cookies, they will firm up as they cool.

Allow cookies to cool on the baking sheet for 10-15 minutes before transferring to a cooling rack to cool completely.

If desired make up a batch of browned butter glaze and drizzle on top of cooled cookies, top cookies with a little fresh grated nutmeg.

Notes

The post is written with high altitude instructions, for sea level reduce the flour to 2 ½ cups.

Store in airtight container on counter for up to 1 week or freeze up to 6 months.

Did you make this recipe?

Go ahead, MAKE MY DAY! PIN on Pinterest and Comment on the blog!

kathleen

ABOUT KATHLEEN

I enjoy sharing easy recipes that are wholesome and delicious. I am fed by my faith, family, friends & food! Welcome to my kitchen! Read more...

large cottonwood trees on a trail with a farmhouse in the distance.
Previous
Fresh Fridays, October 23
Image of thanksgiving table with candlesticks, china place settings, apples, natural decor and more.
Next
How To Celebrate Thanksgiving in 2020

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Skip to Recipe